Strategy Books vs Openings Books: Which Should You Read First?

You have one evening and one book budget. On the left, a strategy book that promises to teach you how to think. On the right, an openings book that promises to teach you the moves. Almost every club player faces this choice, and the advice they get is usually too confident in one direction or the other.

Strategy and openings are not rivals. They answer different questions, and one of them is far easier to use once the other is in place. Here is how to decide what to read first, and how to get value from both.

What each type of book actually does

A strategy book teaches you to evaluate. It shows you how to look at a position and say something useful about it: who has the better bishop, which squares are weak, whether the position calls for patience or violence. You meet ideas like the isolated pawn, the outpost, opposite-side castling, and the difference between a pawn break that helps you and one that helps your opponent.

An openings book teaches you a route. It gives you move orders, the reasons behind them, and the typical middlegames you should expect. The good ones explain plans rather than listing variations, but the material is still anchored to specific positions that arise from specific lines.

Why strategy usually comes first

Opening knowledge only pays off if you can recognise the position you have been aiming for. Learn the first fifteen moves of a sharp line and you will still be lost on move sixteen unless you understand what the pawn structure is asking of you. Two players can leave the same opening position and head in completely different directions, because the position supports more than one plan.

There is also a retention argument. Opening lines fade. You forget move eleven of something you learned in March, or your opponent plays a move you have never seen and the whole sequence is in the bin. The ideas underneath survive: central control, development, king safety, the timing of pawn breaks. A player who understands why ...b5 is coming in a Sicilian will cope with unfamiliar move orders far better than someone who has memorised a file.

Strategy books also cover the part of the game you play most often. Most club games are decided after the opening, in positions where both sides are slightly out of book and neither has a clear plan. That is precisely where strategy reading earns its place.

The honest case for openings books

None of that means you should ignore openings. A player with no idea what to do in the first ten moves loses games before strategy gets a chance. There is nothing instructive about being crushed in twelve moves because you allowed a tactic you did not know existed.

A modest repertoire does something more valuable than win games: it makes your games repeatable. Play the same structures with White and the same defences with Black, and you start meeting similar positions, making similar mistakes, and learning from them. The key word is modest. One book on your main opening, or a short repertoire guide, will serve you better than an encyclopaedia that covers everything and explains nothing.

Where players go wrong in both directions

The strategy-only reader can drift into pleasant generalities. Knowing that you should improve your worst-placed piece is not much use if you have no idea how to reach a position where that piece matters. Reading about weak squares without having played the structures that create them is like reading about swimming from a deckchair.

The openings-only reader collects variations like souvenirs: plenty of knowledge, very little understanding. The symptom to watch for is knowing a line to move twenty but not knowing which side of the board to attack on.

A practical reading order

1. Start with one principles book. Something that covers development, central control and basic plans. Read it with a board beside you and play through the examples rather than skimming.
2. Add a collection of annotated complete games. Lightly annotated games, explained in words rather than variations, show you how plans appear move by move. This is often the single most useful book a club player owns.
3. Then pick a small opening repertoire. One opening as White, two as Black at most. Choose lines you enjoy, because you will be playing them for years.
4. Return to strategy with something structural. A book on pawn structures or imbalances will make far more sense now, because you will recognise the positions from your own games.
5. Deepen your openings with a database rather than another book. Focus on plans, transpositions, and the endings your lines tend to reach.

How to read each type differently

Strategy books are for slow reading. Take one idea a week and look for it in your games afterwards. Write down your own evaluation of a position before you read the author's, and if you disagree, work out why.

Openings books are for building and reference. Do not memorise. Ask what each move is for, note the typical plan for both sides, and keep a short file of your own lines. After each game, check where you left your preparation and note what went wrong.

Your next move

If you have read more opening books than strategy books, correct the balance. Buy one strategy book and one short repertoire, read the strategy first, and give each three months. Play games between chapters — reading only sticks when it meets the board.

If you already understand plans and structures, the order reverses, and you can absorb opening material quickly because you know what you are looking for. Either way, the goal is the same: a strategy book tells you what to do with the position you have, and an opening book makes sure you get a decent one.

Photo: Doğan Alpaslan Demir / Pexels